Pete, you call it cynicism, I called it realism.

Sorry but I's gonna lay the bullet points on ya--purely for the sake of clarity since I tend to prattle on once I get started.
1. Agreed. I'm assuming things not proven at this point but since those things are consistent with past performance and align with what we do know ... you get the idea.
2. I'm gonna parse this one like a Jesuit just for a minute as it depends on what we mean by "right". I think some things are being done in fair approximation to right on the details but if by right we mean successful and sustainable then plainly something needs to change 'cus I don't believe things can continue as they have gone before.
3. Emminently reasonable but alas, to date reason has had damned little to do with paintball.

Nor do I disagree with you but I think there is a more important question to be asked.
4. The one you rhetorically pose isn't bad and one I would likely ask if you hadn't beaten me to it but not the one I have in mind. My question is: What are the principle goals of the unified league in running Pro paintball tournaments? The answer might seem self-evident but I don't think it is. I also think I can make the case that even in the instances where we would agree those in charge love the game and want to see it succeed the actual on field competition wasn't always the first priority and that in and of itself was a contributing factor to some of the past failures. It is all well and good for Chi-town to have the right functionaries in the right positions but what matters are the marching orders they are given. An outsider without the boy's club baggage is certainly in a position to effect some changes but I have no idea at all what he wants from paintball.
5. Necessity may very well push this into happening but then paintball really is at the mercy of one man's vision and while you may be comfortable with that from what you know all I know is what's happened so far, what I've heard about the original longer term plans when NPPL was bought out and what I've seen so far and cynical or not, I am somewhat less than inspired.
6. and beyond the where does he plan to take the game question we are left with a host of "practical" issues like rules, formats, personnel, etc. that would all need to be resolved between Commander's Cup and HB. Even with the best of intentions this isn't going to be easy.
7. I tell cynicism not on the first date, I'm an old-fashioned kinda guy, unless of course cynicism is a curvy redhead ...
Regardless of my opinion I'm sure the Wheels of Progrees will continue to grind.